November 17, 2014

House Dems Concerned About Electoral College Legislation

Bill would split up electoral votes rather than winner-take-all

LANSING – State Representative Harold L. Haugh (D-Roseville), minority vice-chairman of the House Elections and Ethics Committee, along with committee members Reps. Andy Schor (D-Lansing) and Marilyn Lane (D-Fraser) voiced their concern over House Bill 5974, which would change the way Electoral College votes in presidential elections are allocated in Michigan by eliminating the current winner-take-all system of awarding presidential electors and replace it with a proportional system of awarding electors among the top two candidates of the popular vote count. The committee took testimony today on the bill.

“I always was taught that you play by the rules of the game and if you don’t win, you don’t get to change the rules of the game” said Rep. Haugh.

Under the bill debated today in committee, nine of Michigan’s current 16 Electoral College votes would go to the presidential candidate who won the state and the other seven would be distributed based on a percentage of the margin of victory.

The change is seen by many as a way for Republicans to turn the tide in their favor when it comes to GOP presidential hopefuls performing better in Michigan. Republicans claim the change is necessary for Michigan to become more relevant to presidential candidates in both parties.

“This bill does nothing to attract presidential candidates and resources to Michigan,” said Rep. Schor. “In fact, it lowers the possibility. In a close race, this proposal would have the top two candidates competing for 2 or 3 electoral votes instead of our current 16. In a state of almost 10 million people, our influence would be reduced to that Delaware (925,000 people). It seems to me that the Republicans are throwing up the white flag, saying they can never win Michigan, and taking what they can get instead of competing for all 16 electoral votes.

“Also, this hasn’t worked in other states, and they have not attracted presidential candidates.”

In the 2012 presidential election, President Barack Obama won the popular vote in Michigan over Mitt Romney, 2,564,569 to 2,115,256, thus earning all of the state’s 16 electoral votes. With this legislation, President Obama would have won Michigan’s 12 electoral votes, giving Romney four.

“Fundamental to our democracy is the concept of one person, one vote,” Rep. Lane said. “This legislation undermines that principle and threatens Michigan’s influence in presidential elections. Candidates should win on their merits, not by rigging the system.”

How can I help?

Please let me know how I can be of assistance to you so that together, we can continue to make progress in our community.

Office Address
N795 House Office Building

Mailing Address
P.O. Box 30014
Lansing, MI 48909-7514

Phone: (517) 373-0159
Fax: (517) 373-5893

(877) 347-8031


View District Map
June 13, 2014

Rep. Lane Says Lack of Political Courage Scuttled Roads Plan

Lane offers her road bills to protect roads, motorists

June 12, 2014

House Dems: Legislative Republicans’ Spectacular Road Funding Failure Betrays Michigan Voters

Republicans decide to take a vacation rather than find road funding solution

April 21, 2014

Rep. Lane Says No to Insurance Hikes for Pothole Damage

Rep. Lane Says No to Insurance Hikes for Pothole Damage


Sign up for my E-newsletter Updates

Select Marilyn Lane as your Representative

I’m State Representative Marilyn Lane, and I serve Michigan’s 31st House District.

Thank you for taking a moment to visit my website. I hope you’ll find the information that I’ve provided helpful. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions, or concerns about state government or available services. I’m here to serve you.


Marilyn Lane

State Representative Marilyn Lane

31st House District

Official PhotoPhoto GalleryVideo Gallery